Midnight Drive The Owner's Course
Module 6 tool

The catalogue. One lot per product Google sells.

Paid ads are an auction house, and this is the catalogue. Every lot makes someone money. The question is fit: a high ticket, local, considered purchase with demand that already exists. The description is neutral. The appraisal is the opinion.

Use it at your next review meeting, or when a new channel is proposedPrint it fits on one page
Lot 01

Search

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click
Catalogue description

Text ads on Google results. The customer types what they want, you choose which searches to pay for, you pay per click.

Where it sells well

Any business whose customers search for it by name of service. Declared intent.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursThe baseline

Someone told you what they want and where. Controllable, measurable, and the standard everything else on this page is compared against. Most of your budget belongs here: one campaign per service, one ad group in it, one responsive search ad.

the one lot worth bidding on
Lot 02

Performance Max

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click, placement chosen by Google
Catalogue description

One budget spent across search, display, video, Gmail, and maps. Google decides placement. Reporting shows outcomes without showing where they came from.

Where it sells well

Catalogs and volume. Ecommerce with hundreds of products, where averages work and any single sale is small.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursPoor fit

It absorbs searches for your own shop name and credits them to itself, so the numbers look good. On takeovers the conversions usually turn out to be brand searches and cheap display clicks. If it runs at all, brand must be excluded and results read with brand removed. Ask what it displaces in the Search budget.

looks good in the catalogue, read the provenance
Lot 03

Display

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click, placement chosen by Google
Catalogue description

Banner ads on other people’s websites and apps, shown to someone doing something else.

Where it sells well

Awareness at scale. Retail launches. Brands with a long buying cycle and a national audience.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursPoor fit

There is no intent, so results depend entirely on how results are defined. The clicks are cheap, and the cheapness is the tell. It has not earned a place in any account we manage. Retargeting past visitors is a fair use on social, covered in Module 7, and that is a different product from Google’s display network.

a third of the bids in this room are accidental
Lot 04

Video

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click or per view
Catalogue description

Ads on YouTube, before or during videos. Paid per view or per thousand impressions.

Where it sells well

Brand building over a long horizon, with a budget that can wait for it.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursBrand spend, not lead spend

It can work, on a horizon most shops are not funding. If it is in your account, ask which budget it comes out of and judge it as brand spend. If it was sold to you as a lead channel, that is the mismatch.

brand money, label it that way
Lot 05

Demand Gen

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click, placement chosen by Google
Catalogue description

Image and video ads across YouTube, Discover, and Gmail, targeted by audience rather than search.

Where it sells well

Visual products that people did not know they wanted. Same logic as paid social.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursPoor fit

Interruption, not intent. Apply the Module 7 test: a considered purchase in a small metro market, reached by interrupting people who were not looking. Expect lead volume with a low close rate.

same lot as social, different auctioneer
Lot 06

Shopping

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click, placement chosen by Google
Catalogue description

Product listings with a photo and a price, fed from a product catalog.

Where it sells well

Selling physical products online.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursNot applicable

Unless you sell products online. A service has no catalog. If it appears in your account, ask why.

wrong sale
Lot 07

Local Services Ads

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper lead
Catalogue description

The Google Guaranteed listings above the regular ads, for certain licensed trades. Paid per lead rather than per click.

Where it sells well

Home services where Google offers the category and the lead is a phone call.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursDepends on availability

Only where Google offers a matching category in your market. Where it exists, it is intent based and worth testing on its own line. Where it does not, anyone selling it to you is selling something else.

ask if the room even exists in your market
Lot 08

Search partners

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click
Catalogue description

A setting, not a product. Your Search ads shown on sites that are not Google. On by default.

Where it sells well

Extra reach when the main auction is exhausted and the partner sites are relevant.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursOff, always

Cheaper clicks that convert worse, and rarely mentioned in a report. Off in every account we manage. Check it yourself: segment by network in your own account. A provider who does not know whether it is on has answered the question.

a side room they enter you into by default
Lot 09

Broad match

Sold byGoogle
Biddingper click
Catalogue description

A match type, not a product, but it gets proposed like one. Google decides what counts as related to your keyword.

Where it sells well

Large accounts with clean conversion data and daily attention, where the machine has enough signal to learn from.

Appraisal for a shop like yoursOnly with daily attention

Related is generous. Without someone reading the search terms every day it drifts into house windows, window repair, car washes, and DIY, and trains the account on the wrong customer. Exact and phrase by default.

the auctioneer bids on your behalf

Three questions for any recommended channel

Intent

What intent does this reach? Someone who typed the service, or someone who was doing something else?

Attribution

How will results be attributed? Will it be credited for enquiries that were coming anyway?

Budget

What does it displace in the budget? Every dollar here is a dollar not on declared intent.